
Pantser Peril: Journal Sex (AKA Lack of Conflict)
My writing process has changed over the years. I started out as a serious plotter. I filled out the character worksheets, developed a detailed plot, broke down each scene in great detail… and it worked. For a while. Then life threw a few curveballs my way, and — whether because of the turmoil or despite it — my process changed. I became an organic writer, AKA: a pantser (someone who writes by the seat of her pants).
The pantser process has its benefits, but it also has a ton of potential pitfalls. While my characters often lead me in myriad wonderful directions I never anticipated, not knowing who these story people are until I start writing about them can lead to…
… well, to journal sex.
To what, you’re asking?
Yeah, you heard me. Journal sex.
Journal sex is what happens when the author knows she has to meet her editor’s quota of erotic content (moresex, moresex, moresex — check!), but has no clue how to add it in. But I digress. Let me go back to the beginning.
I recently started a new WIP. I sold the book on proposal, which meant I already knew where the story was going. At least in theory. What I hadn’t quite determined out was how I’d get there. No big deal, I figured. I’ve done this before. My characters will lead the way. With that firm belief in mind, I started to write.
After 2,500 words, I lifted my head from the word fog and found that my hero spent four pages shopping for a pen, and the rest of the time writing in his journal — with said pen, of course. If you’ve ever kept a journal, you know they’re perfect for venting, and pining, and wishing, and hoping… which is all this poor guy did. Only he did it in explicit, X-Rated detail.
And oh, boy, was it bad.
The problem (beyond the journal sex), was a distinct Lack Of Conflict. Yes, the concept is important enough that it deserves to be capitalized.
Instead of starting in the middle of things, I started much too early. A week too early, to be exact. Oh, things would eventually happen to this man, but they weren’t happening now.
There’s only one way to fix this kind of issue when you’re mired in a dull, pointless scene that’s going nowhere, and it’s not pretty, but it’s necessary. Scrap all the words, and start over. But before you do that, take a few minutes to figure out your scene. If you’re a pantser, rest easy — I won’t suggest you plot. What I advise is asking yourself a few questions:
- Who is the central character in his scene?
- What does he want?
- Why can’t he have it? (This is critical)
- Does he get it what he wants by the end of this scene? (There are only three possible answers to this question: “No.”, “No, and furthermore…”, “Yes, but…” Never let your character get what he wants without having his prize complicate matters even more, unless you’re about to tack THE END to the last sentence of that scene.)
Do that, and I promise you’ll never have to experience the agony of writing journal sex.
(image by: isazappy)








Excellent post Lace! And I still think you should print out and frame the journal sex to keep by your desk LOL!
Excellent website and post Lacey and Fiona. This is such a wonderful reference for writers and for folks who enjoy reviewing alike.
Also, I wanted to say the site is just beautiful!!
Thank you both for sharing your expertise with us.
Best
L
Lol, I’d never heard of journal sex before. Great post.
LOL–love it Lacey, especially about the four pages of pen-buying. Well, he did have to choose the proper tool for journal sex.
No, seriously, well said. No conflict, no story. And it’s interesting to think, if you just change the time line, suddenly…viola! Conflict-city.
Now…this blog is darling! I love it. Who was the main creator, since I know both you and Fi are talented at this sort of thing.
Awesome site! What a good idea. I love the “Pantser” expression. I hate to compare everything to sports but it sounds like you do better when you don’t overthink it & just go with the flow. It sounds like “just do it”.
Interesting and funny post, Lacey. I’m looking forward to reading more from both you and Fi. Wonderful blog.
~Bryl
Great blog! And I love the post. Never heard of journal sex before,but I’ve done my share of padding the word count with useless scences .
Hi Lea – thanks for stopping by! We figured as much as we talk about “craft”, we should do something fun and productive with it.
LOL Mary – you got the Nike logo in my head now:)
LOL Honoria – it was a first time I heard of it as well.
Hi Bryl! Thx for visiting!!
Hiya Beth – thanks! Lace found the graphic of the lady and the cat – and its so similar to our writing (with feline supervision) that the rest of site’s look and feel sort of grew from that one graphic.
Hi Anne – thanks for commenting! I think we’ve all done something to pad the word count – at least on the first draft. I’m guilty of leaving notes to myself for future revisions and including it in the word count – in the first draft at least:)
Excellent post. I wish I’d read it a few years ago. I tried pantsing once. I wound up with an epic saga that spanned 1300 years and 1500 pages. Needless to say it was unpublishable, but it did leave me with a half-dozen very well defined characters. I imagine that I’ll resurrect them someday.
Thanks for the tips. I love this business. I learn something new every day; frequently several things.
grbretz
Delightfully Disturbing Daydreams
Wow! Lacy and Fiona you guys have put together some really great information all into one place. And as usual you do it with a bit of fun! Thanks so much for the tips and allowing me to take a peek. To be honest though, I might look more than once. Don’t be surprised if you see me lurking around in here from time to time.
~Nicole
Thanks for dropping by, everyone. What a fabulous way to launch a new blog!
Lea — We look forward to seeing you back here again soon!
Honoria — And may you never hear of it again! LOL
Beth — It’s funny how such a relatively minor thing like fast-forwarding a few days can make such a huge difference in the way the story unfolds. Elmore Leonard once said he tries “not to write the parts people skip.” I think that’s fabulous advice!
Mary — It’s so rewarding when you go with the flow and the characters surprise you. It’s not nearly as much fun when you flow right into snooze-ville. LOL
Bryl — Thanks for dropping by!
Anne — Ah, useless sentences… I know that ailment well, too. I had to do the opposite just recently and ruthlessly cut everything that wasn’t vital to the story so I could stick to a very demanding word count. The book was much better for it, but I have trouble forcing myself to do that with everything I write. I naturally assume that longer = better, when that’s simply not the case.
grbretz — Are you a fantasy fan, by chance?
I’m reminded of those giant epic fantasy door stoppers. I’m a huge fan of epic fantasy, but man, some of those monsters could use a ruthless editor.
Nicole — We hope to entice you back often!
I wonder if I’m the only one who *likes* the journal sex idea? I can see conflict there. A hot man with a shy exterior who treats a certain woman with the utmost respect during daylight hours, but who writes down all his steamy, over-the-top, I wanna tie you to the bed and F-you six ways to Sunday thoughts in his journal each night. And maybe, while said woman enjoys being treated w/kid gloves – to a certain extent – she’d also like to have a man who will take her against the wall now and then.
Might need tweaked, and would need to morph as time goes on (no “big misunderstandings), but I could see this working out quite well. Really hot, and probably humorous.
But I’d definitely nix the whole 4 pages of pen-buying.
Very nice site, ladies. I’ll definitely drop in to read your posts as often as possible.